The 250 Mbps Cap
Every DCP — whether 2K or 4K — is subject to a maximum picture bitrate of 250 megabits per second. This is the DCI specification. It does not matter how large the image is: the cinema pipeline has a hard ceiling of 250mbps.
A 4K image contains four times as many pixels as a 2K image. Both are constrained to the same maximum data rate. So a 4K DCP is encoding four times the spatial information within the same bandwidth envelope — each pixel gets a quarter of the data budget on average.
The 2K Substream Problem
DCP picture is encoded in JPEG2000, which encodes resolution in layers. A 4K DCP played on a 2K projector discards the upper resolution layers and renders a 2K image from the lower ones. But that 2K substream extracted from a 4K DCP has a lower effective bitrate than a natively encoded 2K DCP running at the same overall data rate.
At The Post Factory, we encode 2K DCPs at up to 140 mbps — well above most defaults, and carefully chosen to give the JPEG2000 codec sufficient headroom for the most demanding content: film grain, fast motion, fine texture, dark scenes with subtle shadow detail. A 140 mbps 2K DCP will often look better than the 2K substream from a 4K DCP on a 2K projector.
When Is 4K the Right Choice?
A 4K DCP makes genuine sense when your film will play on a native 4K projector — and there are more of these now, particularly in premium large format screens. When the BBC Natural History Unit want to premiere a new production and demonstrate what their cinematographers achieved shooting in native 4K, they will specifically choose a 4K venue and we will make a native 4K DCP. Every pixel counts in that context and the whole point of the screening is to show what the format is capable of.
A film is not always about pixels. Some of the most powerful films ever made were shot on 16mm or grainy high-speed stock. Resolution is a tool — its value depends entirely on whether it serves what the film is trying to do.
Our Recommendation
For most independent films on the festival circuit: a well-encoded 2K DCP will serve you excellently in the vast majority of venues. If specific 4K venues are on your distribution plan, a 4K DCP is worth having alongside the 2K version — which is why when clients bring us UHD source material and want 4K, we include a 2K DCP as part of the same package. One mastering session, two deliverables. The 4K version for screens that can show it at its best, and a 2K version that outperforms the substream everywhere else. This costs approximately 30% more than a single 2K DCP.
Want the right resolution for your film?
Tell us about your source material and distribution plan.
Get a Quote →